Good Design Can Overcome Community Opposition to Affordable Housing - 2/21/2005 - Home Remodeling Interior Decorating Design

Good Design Can Overcome Community Opposition to Affordable Housing

“Higher design quality may be the single most cost-effective strategy currently available to improve the quality, asset value and acceptance of affordable housing,” say the report’s authors, Deane Evans and Jody Beck of the New Jersey Institute of Technology Center for Architecture and Building Science Research.

“Good design can be the critical difference between an affordable development that succeeds — one that satisfies its residents and neighbors, enhances the community where it is built and remains a stable part of that community long after the ribbon is cut — and one that doesn’t,” the report says.

While much of the public resistance to affordable housing is “self-serving,” the report also acknowledges that, “A legacy of large, poorly designed affordable housing projects has been firmly established in the public imagination, and this is what opponents often envision when a new development is proposed.”

Elements of good design, according to the report, can include:

• Paths and walkways that are pleasurable to use
• A visually complex and interesting building façade
• Open spaces designed like “outdoor rooms”
• Unit layouts that provide access to daylight and views in every room
• Parking plans that minimize interaction between vehicles and pedestrians

The report advocates designs that meet the needs of occupants, respond to the building’s physical context and enhance their neighborhoods. Projects should also be “built to last,” the report says, “by using materials, systems and finishes that are durable, easy to maintain and energy-efficient.”

As evidence that good design is too expensive for affordable projects, community development organizations often point to the high cost of well-designed, market-rate housing, the report says. But costs of market-rate housing are higher primarily because they provide more and better amenities, such as larger spaces, more expensive appliances, better finishes and fixtures. “None of these amenities, however, is central to achieving design quality,” the report says.

The report recommends the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Affordable Housing Design Advisor as a resource; the Web site contains 80 case studies of well-designed projects that were developed within the cost constraints confronting affordable housing developers.